Luckyscent
Fragrance X
Indiescents
First in Fragrance
99Perfume
ExcelsisUSA
Parfum1
My Photo
Name:
Location: New York, NY
© Copyright 2005-2011 Perfume-Smellin' Things
All rights reserved
Custom Search

Friday, October 27, 2006

Perfume Review: Le Labo Tubereuse 40

I did not want to like Tubereuse 40 at all, just as a matter of principle. It is a first in a series of future Le Labo scents that would be specific to only one location. Tubereuse 40 is specific to New York and can only be purchased at the Le Labo boutique there (sort of like Lutens' "exclusive" concept taken to absolute extreme; only in the case of non-export bell jars, at least the rest of Europe can still purchase them online). Don’t try to order the new Le Labo fragrance over the phone or online. You have to physically be there to be able to part with your hard-earned $230-$360. And if you are in Rio de Janeiro or Vladivostok? Well, apparently Le Labo is “nostalgic of the days where brands and their soul offered authenticity that deserved that little extra travel commitment”. The city-specific fragrances is Le Labo’s “own little contribution to the fight against globalization”. Isn’t it one of the most attractive qualities of perfume that it is a luxury that one can more or less afford? I can’t buy couture clothes, but I can once in a while treat myself to a bottle of something fabulously glamorous. But when a brand forces me to pay the cost of “that little extra travel commitment”, what it is essentially doing is robbing me of the one small luxury I could previously enjoy. And all this somewhat nonsensical, rather obnoxiously elitist concept presented in terms of the fight against globalization quite frankly raises my hackles. If there is one thing that I hate, it is when "politics" is brought into perfume (MoslBuddWhatever, anyone?). They say, revolution, they say, unconventional. I say, pretentious and annoying.

So, yes, I was a little prejudiced against Tubereuse 40. But its beauty broke through the gloomy cloud of my bias like a ray of proverbial sunshine. This is the essence of summer, bottled. Created by Alberto Morillas, the scent was meant to be “a non-heady Tubereuse shaped around citruses and musks that give it an unexpected unisex “eau de cologne” identity despite its impressive 30% dosage of oil in alcohol.” That means that the fragrance has the general feel of cologne but wears like a sumptuous, rich eau de parfum. It is lush, substantial and exceptionally long-lasting on my skin. The top notes of Tubereuse 40 have a slightly chilly, almost mentholated quality that makes the composition immediately uplifting. The citruses are succulent and fresh. Fresh as in freshly picked and freshly squeezed. Lemons, mandarins, bitter oranges are ripe, bursting with juices, their mouthwatering tangy-ness highlighted by the presence of a delicate herbal accord. The orange blossoms, which start to flourish in the heart of the scent, are bright and poignantly summery, their sunny frailty underscored by a gentle mimosa note and beautiful, soft jasmine. Tubereuse 40 is youthful, joyful, lively. It is an olfactory equivalent of sunshine.

And now I am coming to the question of tuberose, which I tried to avoid as long as possible, simply because I don’t know how to account for the absence of the title note on my skin. But the truth is, as far my nose is concerned, there is no tuberose in Tubereuse 40. Or there is so little of it that it is lost under the gorgeous lusciousness of citrus fruits, orange blossom and jasmine. My very humble theory is as follows: like seemingly patchouli-less Patchouli 24 was meant to evoke the dark, velvety essence of patchouli without actually smelling like patchouli, so Tubereuse 40 is not a realistic representation, but an artist’s abstract idea of the flower. This is a portrait of tuberose in its youth, drawn using the brightest of colors, mostly yellows in all possible shades. ...Or to be completely honest, I really have no idea why the scent named after tuberose would not smell like tuberose, not even non-heady tuberose. And I don’t really care. I am not even that big a fan of tuberose. Despite the mystery of the name and the irritating concept, I love this scent. It is going to brighten the dreary winter days ahead like few perfumes can. It will help to transport me from the miserable cold reality to an imaginable place, somewhere in the South of France, where I am carefree and tanned, in a white cotton dress, sitting in a chaise longue, sunshine hot on my face, enveloping my skin, chasing away the cold from my bones…

As I mentioned above, Tubereuse 40 costs $230.00 (50ml)-$360.00 USD (100ml), or $90 for 1/2oz (thank you, Judith!). And that is not counting “that little extra” expense of traveling to NYC.
*
The first image is from LeLabo.com. The second from Allposters.com.

46 Comments:

Anonymous Ina said...

Brilliant review, Marina! I thoroughly enjoyed reading it, and it made me literally crave the juicy citrus as well as the fragrance itself. :) Just as a side note, it's also available at the NYC Barney's. I believe the idea is to have each Barney's store in the U.S. have their own Le Labo scent, so they started with NYC, for obvious reasons. The next one will be in Dallas.

11:37 PM EDT  
Blogger colombina said...

Ina,
But they won't ship if you call or go online, right? At least that's what the press release is saying. :-( I quote: "the Internet and phone will be useless, you will have to travel to get it. Sorry"

11:39 PM EDT  
Anonymous Ina said...

Hmm, bizarre. If it's at Barney's, then why not? They ship everything else. Very bizarre and pretentious, I agree.

11:44 PM EDT  
Blogger colombina said...

And like, if it's at Barneys and a customer calls to buy and asks for this, what is a poor SA to do? To tell him or her, no madam/sir, I cannot sell you this scent even though you are prepared to spend that much money with us, no, no way, I have my instructions.
...Bizarro.

11:48 PM EDT  
Blogger boisdejasmin said...

Great review! I must say that I find the concept silly, especially when the fight against globalization is added to the mixture. I also balk at the price, but I so enjoy this fragrance after having had a chance to wear it on my skin. South of France is indeed right. :)

11:49 PM EDT  
Blogger colombina said...

Vika,
Thank you!
The more I wear the more I love it. So bright, so "juicy", just beautiful. And such great sillage too. And longlasting. I so wish it was more affordable.

11:52 PM EDT  
Blogger tmp00 said...

Jeesh- and I was just commenting on Perfume Posse that I sort of like the idea that you can't ge everything all the time: loving the chase and all. But deep down, I want what I want. Especially if I am calling Barneys with my Barneys cardin my hand.

If they dare tell me that they will not ship Patchouli 24 to the west coast, I would seriously board JetBlue just to bit#h-slap them.

11:59 PM EDT  
Anonymous timam said...

I love the witty review, M! *the essence of a summer* also sounds more than promising to me. now all I have to do is jump on the plane to NYC and take my many golden credit cards along - which (both) shouldn't be too difficult or time-consuming at all. I'm sure we'll all meet in Le Labo in the Big Apple ;-)

2:02 AM EDT  
Blogger chaya ruchama said...

Loved the review, and I also share your reluctance, both to part w/ the cash, or to travel to NYC for this.

I'm going to sit back on this one.

My Tabarome arrived, intact, yesterday, and I'm layering and glorying in tobacco, amber, and ambergris like a pig rooting in muck !

When it gets cold, I crave animalic, winey, boozy, spicy, incensey- very rarely floral [unless it's decadently moody and abysmally dark].

Love you-
Enjoy the w/e !

7:19 AM EDT  
Blogger elle said...

OK, you do understand that I have a tight budget right now? I was practically purring w/ satisfaction yesterday at hearing that this was more along the lines of an Eau de Cologne than a tuberose scent since I don't really care for EdCs. Then you have to go and write this review that makes me totally forget that I don't care for EdCs and even forget the obnoxious exclusivity...suddently this is a lemming of the first order. My cc is sobbing in the corner.

7:22 AM EDT  
Blogger lilyofbp said...

Well, I feel I should mention (purely for informational purposes) that it is also available in the small, 1/2 oz. size at the Le Labo store (though not at Barney's) for about $90. I know this because, um, I bought it, and I'm wearing it right now. Your review captures it wonderfully (although I do get tuberose underneath it all in the drydown--at least I have persuaded myself that I do:). And I have to add that this is one of the very few citrus-inflected scents that works on me (although the citrus goes away after the beginning). That said, I agree that the single-city concept is silly--although it somehow seems to make more sense when the VERY cute Fabrice and Eddie explain it:)

7:52 AM EDT  
Blogger colombina said...

Tom,
Oh, don't give them ideas!
It's funny though that they encourage us to travel while at the same time "fighting" the globalization. Because aren't practically unlimited opportunities to travel and to travel fast what aid the globalization in the first place? Now, if they said, we will sell you this only if you walk or ride a horse driven carriage to our boutique...now that would be a concept thought through to its logical end :-)

8:42 AM EDT  
Blogger colombina said...

Tina,
Thank you! And, yes, why don;t you just jump on that plane. It's just a little extra inconvinience, that's all :-)

8:44 AM EDT  
Blogger lilyofbp said...

OK, having given this a chance to dry down, I will say that I definitely smell tuberose now (I don't THINK I'm fooling myself:)

8:45 AM EDT  
Blogger colombina said...

Chaya,
Congratulations on Tabaroma!
I usually crave the exact same things you described, but every winter there comes a time, usually in Jan-Feb, when I just can't stand the cold anymore. I rebel. :-) And that is when I need scents like Tubereuse 40. :

8:46 AM EDT  
Blogger colombina said...

L,
Well, unless you are going to NYC in the near future, your CC can wipe its tears and relax for a while. :-)

8:47 AM EDT  
Blogger colombina said...

Judith,
Thank you for the info! I saw the photos, they do seem to be very cute :-) No wonder you caved...So, $90 for 1/2oz, twice the price of their regular 1/2oz bottles. *sigh*

8:48 AM EDT  
Blogger colombina said...

Judith,
Is it a nice tuberose? I am sure it is lovely... I am asking because I just don't smell it there. Sometimes I tell myself that I do, but really...I don't :-) Which, for me, might be a good thing actually.

8:49 AM EDT  
Blogger Christina H. said...

I'm very annoyed at this foolish concept too! Elitist and priced that way too. All I can do is wish on them very poor sales of it! Then, maybe they'll consider the concept of "for limited time only, you may purchase Tubereuse 40 online!"

I can hope, because your review sounds so lovely! I'd love to try this but I'm not going to shell out even more dough to get there for the privilege of trying it! Hummphh!

Thank you for the lovely review though!

8:54 AM EDT  
Blogger lilyofbp said...

Yes, lovely--and not heady at all. Unless, of course, I am fooling myself--I am not the best on notes; you are much better--but I know Nancy smelled it, too (maybe, though, we are dealing with the Emperor's new Tuberose here:). There's clearly jasmine there, too,
so. . . OH! I know how to certify my impression--I have a friend who HATES Tuberose, and she can always sniff it out, so I will check with her, but for now--I say that it's there and it's lovely!:) The price I gave isn't exact; and, in the defense of the buyers, we DID get 10% off (which only covered the sales tax, in this case:)

8:59 AM EDT  
Blogger colombina said...

Christina,
That's exactly how it feels to me too, like it's a priviledge to buy it. I have to jump through hoops to spend my $300. Shouldn't it be the other way round, should the sellers jump through hoops to get my money? I've jumped through enough hoops already, what with the bell jars and exclusive Guerlains. I've reached my limit of tolerance for that kind fo thing :-)

9:07 AM EDT  
Blogger colombina said...

Judith,
The Emperor's new Tuberose! Wonderful. And so true! :-)

9:08 AM EDT  
Anonymous Sariah said...

There is always EBAY. I see that samples of this are already available for about $10 on the bay, and I suppose it’s only a matter of time before decants are available, so I don’t know how successful they will be in maintaining their vision of having people actually coming to the store in person to get it. I love the store and will certainly be back next time I’m in NYC, I want to take my husband to smell the raw materials they have in jars, the “olfactionary”, and the other things they have to smell like ambergris tincture in the fridge. Going into the store is a great experience, and buying a fragrance there is like having a souvenir as well as a perfume. I’m a big collector of rocks, shells, fossils and beach glass. There are prettier rocks in museum stores here, and faux fossils, but they just aren’t appealing to me because they have no sense of place. My favorite t-shirt is from a tiny store in my tiny town, handmade by a local woman who only made 2 in each color. I treasure my bottles of Santal de Mysore and Jicky EDP that I bought in Paris and cannot get anywhere in the US, and wearing them reminds me of Paris, whereas my bottle of Chergui from Barney’s just isn’t as special.

So if I like it, and I can’t get it where I am, that’s OK with me. I can’t get my favorite cheese here, but I hope to go back to Quebec someday and have it again, or discover a new one. And maybe if I tasted it here in my house, it wouldn’t taste as good as it did then on fresh baked bread sitting on a tiny table outside of the bakery with my good friends that I was traveling with.

Looks like I'm in the minority here though by not finding this concept annoying....... oh well.

Sariah

9:19 AM EDT  
Blogger colombina said...

Sariah,
I understand your point and the appeal of unique things that can only be bought in certain places.
It is strange to me though that Le Labo decided to turn a scent as interesting,lovely and as perhaps universally apealing into basically a souvenir.

And also, yes, we have to accept that some things can't be bought where we are. I can't get foods I love here, for example, etc. But shouldn't we aim to achieve a state of things where everything is available or at least a mouse-click away? A phone-call away? I understand that a small-scale cheese producer in some faraway corner of the earth might not have an opportunity to open an online store or have a catalogue, but Le Labo don't have such limitations, so why impose those limitations on themselves? Why regress instead of progress? Why make it difficult for people to buy their product instead of making it easy? I don't get it.

9:28 AM EDT  
Anonymous newproducts said...

Unlike you M, I have no objection mixing politics with perfume. :)
However, I completely agree with you that this sounds like pretentious pseudo-politics. I have no problem not even sampling the thing so as not to be tempted just for principle's sake. I must say though, your revciew of it sounds luscious, what with the abstract idea of tuberose rather than the real thing (and that pic in your review! Ooooh, aaaah!).

10:00 AM EDT  
Blogger colombina said...

M,
Ooooh, aaaah - that's exactly the type of response I like to get :-)

And I am so looking forward to reading your articles for perfumecritic.com!

10:25 AM EDT  
Anonymous Sariah said...

Hi Marina,

I understand your point – the cheese maker probably doesn’t have the resources to put his cheese for sale online, but Le Labo could easily make this available on their online store or other store locations.

I understand their point too. I’m sure running their little shop in NYC is not cheap. They have a very knowledgeable person there for you to talk to and mix your fragrance freshly on the spot. I’m sure it would be less expensive for them just to sell via the online shop and Barney’s. But I would be really sad if that happens. I love the shop, and this isn’t just the case for Le Labo. Sometimes I will knowingly pay more to buy something in a store than what it would cost me online because I like to shop in person, I like to talk to the knowledgeable people in the store and I like to test things in store. I don’t know Le Labo’s full motivation behind having this fragrance be exclusive to in-person shoppers, but I would totally understand it as an incentive to get people to come into the store. I really hope my favorite perfume stores don’t disappear in the face of E-Bay, Perfumebay, Barney’s online etc. So I confess I am a little bit anti-progress in this regard.

If nothing else it makes for an interesting discussion. Thanks,

Sariah

10:49 AM EDT  
Blogger colombina said...

Thank you, Sariah!
I just love the convinience of everytthing being available online at all times. If I want to buy Tubereuse 40, I want to buy it *now*, without having to make any extra effort and paying any more money to travel to NYC. I am lazy like that :-)

10:55 AM EDT  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I too am a non-tuberose lover who fell in love with Tuberose 40 at first sniff. It's listed in the most recent Barney's beauty catalog so I'm thinking they wouldn't waste pages on items that one cannot order?? Just a thought. Thanks for an as-always lovely and intriguing review.

cheers, Sara

11:32 AM EDT  
Blogger Fragrant Funster said...

The juice sounds lovely. The concept? Silly really. You see, I was a very bad scentoholic and wrote Le Labo an e-mail asking if in their fight against globalization all the natural essences in the Juice were Fair Trade sourced and if all the chemicals were created by companies who strictly enforced fair labor practices in all their plants worldwide.

They sent me a very polite and pleasant non-answer inviting me to stop in for a sniff if I was ever in NYC. Unfortunately they did not forward a voucher for the airfare.

le sigh...so much for an attempt at creative monkeywrenching

12:56 PM EDT  
Blogger colombina said...

Sara,
Thank you!
Ina and I were pondering the Barney question yesterday. I don't get it. What's the point of feturing this scent in a catalogue if one can only buy it in person. It's just all so unnecessarily complicated.

12:59 PM EDT  
Blogger colombina said...

FF,
I salute you, brava! Very good point about Fair Trade, etc. All that "fight against globalziation" concept of theirs is just a lot of trendy yada yada yada. The perfume itself is just grogeous though, Arrgh.

1:01 PM EDT  
Blogger elle said...

Marina,
I'm pinning my hopes on ebay. After that would be a quick weekend trip to NY - used to do that a lot when the budget was less beleaguered. But that's not in the budget for any time in the near future. :-( However, what if there is a divine exclusive scent for some place like Houston? Not a chance in Hades I would even want to go there. Ugh.
L

2:07 PM EDT  
Blogger colombina said...

L,
LOL at Houston-exclusive. :-)

And yeah, my hopes are firmly pinned on ebay. *sigh*

2:36 PM EDT  
Blogger Sexy Sadie said...

Great review, have you tries red door velvet?

3:36 PM EDT  
Blogger colombina said...

Thank you, Sadie! I haven't tried that one, is it nice?

5:34 PM EDT  
Anonymous anna said...

I love mail order.
And there are many people who are ill or have fear of airplanes.
Many many reasons why some people can not travel.
Oh!! well some businesses are insensitive.

5:55 PM EDT  
Blogger colombina said...

Anna,
I absolutely agree!

5:59 PM EDT  
Anonymous eaumy said...

I'm always late to the party, just not usually this late.

I'm wondering if it would be possible to put an end to the mystery by asking the guys at Le Labo whether or not it contains tuberose. Like Judith said, I do smell it in there, if only a molecule or two. But, I'm open to the idea that I'm under a spell of self-delusion.

I think the Le Labo guys conflate globalisation and homogenization. The history of the world is a record of ever expanding trade of goods and ideas. It's too late to turn back the clock. And would we really want to? On the other hand, I can understand the antipathy toward homogenization and the catering to the lowest common denominator that often comes with it. But in this case, I think the scent defies the trend toward homogenization in its composition and its pricing. I could afford the smallest size. But how many people can afford it at all? I'm not saying that scents should be priced in order to create "exclusivity." Nor am I endorsing Le Labo's goal. I am trying to say that Le Labo can attain their goal without their city-specific marketing ploy.

1:50 PM EDT  
Blogger colombina said...

Nancy,
What a great point you make! Exactly, it is priced so far above average that it is already "localized" to a very select group who can afford to spend that kind of money on a scent.

1:53 PM EDT  
Blogger NowSmellThis said...

Very late to the party here, but adore the scent itself. Essence of summer is just right, and it will be perfect, therefore, for winter.

Do you know if it is more expensive than the other Le Labos? I've forgotten what they cost.

5:53 PM EDT  
Blogger colombina said...

R,
I think it's almost twice as expensive as the rest of them.

5:55 PM EDT  
Blogger Sexy Sadie said...

Red Door Velvet is great if you like dark tea scents. It is earl grey vith a twist. ;)

4:35 PM EST  
Blogger Cait Shortell said...

Hello,


I agree that this perfume is delightful, way too much money, and sold with a gimmick. At least it's not a gimmick without a good scent, I say. Great review as usual!

2:50 AM EST  
Blogger colombina said...

Sadie,
It sounds great, I must try!

11:55 AM EST  
Blogger colombina said...

Cait,
Thank you. I don't like the globalziation blah blah, I don't like the price, but I love the scent. Love it.

11:56 AM EST  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home